The Communities of Eastern Kings
Prince Edward Island

logo

Lost Love

logo

iceland II
Johanna MacPhail doesn’t make a habit of
hauling out these newspaper clippings that
document the fishing boat crash 40 years
ago that claimed 10 lives, including her
husband John Hendsbee. She only scans
the articles about every five years, on or
near the anniversary of the tragedy.
Guardian photo by Jim Day

BY JIM DAY
The Guardian
February 23, 2007

Sleep did not come easy to Johanna MacPhail on this long ago, unforgettable night.

Savage weather on Feb. 22, 1967, left MacPhail restless with concern over the fate of her husband, John Hendsbee, and nine other crew members aboard the steel dragger Iceland II.

“That was a really bad storm that night,’’ said MacPhail, 63, of Stratford.

“The old house was shaking . . . I would wake up, fall asleep, wake up, and think are they OK, are they alright, this is a terrible storm. Anyway, I finally fell asleep and I dreamed that they were all dead in the water.’’

Soon, she would learn that her disturbing dream was reality — a nightmare that mercifully has never invaded her sleep since that stormy night.

She still marvels, four decades later, over the chilling accuracy of her horrific premonition.

“Really, really weird . . . It really did happen.’’

The Iceland II had in fact gone aground on the rocks off Nova Scotia’s southern shore. The crash claimed the lives of captain Tom Hodder, mate Tony MacDonald and engineer Albert MacDonald, along with Butch O’Hanley, Lee Jenkins, James Carter, Clovis Gallant, Reggie Foote, Clarence Malone and Hendsbee.

MacPhail did not want her husband of four years and four months to set out from the port in Souris 40 years ago for flounder and cod because she knew how fishing could be treacherous in winter.

She didn’t, however, ask him not to go.

He was a fisherman, had been for the past seven or so years. He had never ventured out in winter but jumped at the invitation to be a late addition to this outing.

“He was only going to go for the one trip,’’ said MacPhail, who lived in East Baltic at the time.

“He said, ‘I should be home in about three weeks to a month’.”

He called home on Feb. 17, the day his baby daughter Johanna turned one. The couple’s second child, Clara, was two-and-a-half years old.

He did not call after the Feb. 22 storm and this concerned MacPhail. Prompted by her unsettling dream, she made some calls and received word that the fishing boat was safely in port. She believes this false assurance was delivered by someone who did not feel able to give her the tragic news.

That unpleasant task fell to Fan MacIntyre, a fisherman who had been too ill to join the expedition and that created the opportunity for Hendsbee to join.

MacIntyre showed up at MacPhail’s doorstep with a relative of Hendsbee’s.

“He took me aside and then said, ‘well, they found the boat and there are no survivors’,’’ said MacPhail. “I felt like I had just been hit in the stomach with a plank.’’

MacPhail chose not to go to Nova Scotia to view her husband’s body after learning he had been badly mangled in the rocks.

“I did not want to see him like that,’’ she said.

Hendsbee had told her shortly before setting out aboard the Iceland II that he wanted her to wear his wedding ring if anything happened to him. She scolded him for talking that way, then they laughed about his dramatic request.

“You don’t think you are going to die anyway when you are young,’’ said MacPhail, who was 23 at the time. “So anyway he went out and that (ring) is the only thing I ever got back. I never saw him again.’’

The body was buried in Souris West Cemetery following a closed-casket ceremony.

MacPhail continues to respect what proved to be her husband’s final request. She had the ring reduced so she could wear it on her right hand.

“It’s just something he wanted me to do, so I honoured that,’’ she said.

Still, MacPhail does not to live in the past. She now lives in Stratford with Paul MacPhail, her husband of 37 years. The couple has two children.

Johanna MacPhail only pulls out her newspaper clippings of the disaster once every five or so years on or near the anniversary date.

She doesn’t do anything to mark the sad occasion. She doesn’t need to.

“No, it’s there,’’ she said, tapping her chest. “It’s there in your heart.’’

Copyright
Waldron H. Leard

ekpei.ca

The Sea

e-mail